Legal Eaze # 41 Legal Separation/Small Claims Court

Title: March 22, 2006

Q. What is a legal separation?

A. When parties are uncertain as to whether or not they want to terminate/dissolve their marriage, they can file a proceeding for “legal separation” instead of “dissolution of marriage”. Marital rights and financial responsibilities may be decided by the family law court without dissolving the marriage. The parties can obtain a Judgment of Legal Separation but that does not terminate their marital status, in other words, they are still husband and wife even though legally they have divided all of the community property estate and have resolved child support and spousal support. Legal separation is an alternative to divorce and is generally sought out by the parties when there is breakdown of the marriage. It is sometimes used for religious or personal reasons, such as in order to retain eligibility for medical insurance that would otherwise be lost by a termination of the marriage. This can be a very important consideration where a spouse has a preexisting medical condition for which new coverage would not be obtainable.

Q. How do I file a Small Claims Court case?

A Most state courthouses have a Small Claims court Division. However, you must sue a defendant in the proper court. Generally, you must sue in the city where the defendant lives, or where they agreed to the disputed contract with you, or where the action took place that led to your injury. Businesses can also be sued in any city where they do business. The advantages of suing in Small Claims Court are 1) it's quick 2) it's cheap 3) it's informal 4) there are no lawyers. The disadvantages are 1) if you are the plaintiff and you are not happy with the Court's decision, you cannot appeal 2) no lawyers: if you are unable to present your case persuasively, you may lose. It sometimes helps to have a high-priced mouthpiece used to represent a party. You file your claim and serve the defendant. Have it served by someone other than you. Anyone over the age of 18 can do. Certified mail is sometimes used. The court clerk can do it for a small fee. But if the defendant knows it's a lawsuit, he/she may not sign it. Once served, you must attend the trial hearing. Make sure you have all your photographs and/or documents pertaining to the dispute. Now that you are in court, be clear and concise because the Judge does not have all to listen to you. The Plaintiff goes first, then the defendant. The Judge may ask each of you some questions, then will make a decision.

Maxine de Villefranche is an attorney and civil general practitioner with 13 years of experience. She practices law from her Tehachapi office as well as her Lancaster satellite office. She will answer legal questions posed to her by the readers to the best of her abilities. Email your questions to maxinedev@msn.com or fax to (661)825-8880.